Chinese Journal of Chromatography ›› 2025, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (5): 455-471.DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1123.2024.10032
• Reviews • Previous Articles Next Articles
XING Yuhang1, REN Xiangshan2, LI Donghao1, LIU Lu1,*()
Received:
2024-10-30
Online:
2025-05-08
Published:
2025-05-07
Supported by:
Fig. 2 Membrane separation techniques based on exosome size a. isolation of exosomes by tangential flow filtration[38]; b. schematic diagram of a microfluidic device based on double tangential flow filtration for exosome separation[39]; c. schematic illustration of size-based extracellular vesicle (EV) isolation using the exosome total isolation chip (ExoTIC) device[40]; d. schematic diagram of exosome separation by exosome detection via the ultrafast-isolation system (EXODUS) device; e. schematic diagram of EVs isolated from plasma by porous membrane electrophoresis[42]. NP: negative pressure; AP: air pressure.
Fig. 3 Other microfluidic separation techniques based on the size of exosomes a. schematic representation of deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) pillar array; b. schematic diagram of EVs separation by a viscoelastic microfluidic device[44]; c. schematic representation of dean-flow-coupled elasto-inertial microfluidic chip (DEIC)-based for exosome purification[45]; d. mechanism and schematic diagram of acoustic fluid device[46]; e. operating mechanism of the acoustofluidic centrifuge platform[47]; f. principle and result diagram of exosome separation based on coffee ring effect[48]; g. schematic illustration of the asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) working principle. PEO: poly(oxyethylene); IDTs: interdigitated transducers; PDMS: polydimethyl-siloxane; SAW: surface acoustic waves.
Fig. 4 Separation techniques for exosomes based on surface charge a. EV separation by using agarose gel electrophoresis[53]; b. picture and mechanism of EV/lipoprotein separation device based on sound flow[54]; c. free flow electrophoresis (FFE) chip separation diagram[55]; d. apparatus and mechanism of exosome isolation based on dielectrophoresis[36]. VLDL: very low density lipoprotein; LDL: low density lipoprotein; HDL: high density lipoprotein; BGE: background electrolyte; MV: microvesicles.
Fig. 5 Isolation technique based on immunoaffinity capture of exosomes a. schematic diagram of rotating magnet assembly system (rMAS) system of microfluidic chip and schematic diagram of fluorescence switching mechanism on the surface of carbon nanomaterials during detection of exosome CD63 by magnetic nanosphere fluorescence method[58]; b. schematic diagram of the preparation procedure of the novel immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) material and its application in exosomal proteomics analysis[60]; c. the interaction mechanism of AMB with the phospholipid layer of exosomes and array analysis[61]. R: a circular reservoir; FAM: 6-carboxy fluorescein; TET: tetrahedra.
Microfluidic technology | Advantages | Limitations | Samples | Sample volume | Isolated size/nm | Time/ min | Recovery/ % | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Exosome separation based on size | ||||||||
TFF | high throughput, con- tinuous preparation | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture super- natant, plasma | 6 mL | 0-350 | 200 | 77.80 | [ |
ExoTIC | high recovery rate, easy to operate, short time consuming | low processing volume | cell culture super- natant, urine, plasma | 10 mL | 30-100 | 125 | 90 | [ |
EXODUS | high recovery rate, easy to operate, short time consuming | low processing volume, complex equipment | cell culture super- natant, urine, tears, plasma | 10 mL | 30-200 | 10 | 100 | [ |
Electrophoresis- driven filtration | easy to operate, short time consuming | low processing volume | plasma | 1 mL | 10-400 | 30 | 65 | [ |
Nano-DLD pillar arrays | minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | urine | 10 μL | 20-110 | 50000 | NA | [ |
Viscoelastic fluid separation | high recovery | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | 1 mL | 30-500 | 50 | 86 | [ |
Inertial microflu- idics | minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | 1 mL | 0-400 | 100 | 70.60 | [ |
Acoustofluidic technology | minimal damage | complex operation | saliva | NA | 30-150 | 20 | 75 | [ |
Acoustofluidic centrifuge | high recovery rate, short time consuming | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | plasma | 80 μL | 30-150 | <1 | >80 | [ |
Coffee ring effect | minimal damage | cannot be collected | cell culture supernatant | NA | 100-200 | NA | NA | [ |
AF4 | minimal damage | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | NA | 35-150 | 50 | NA | [ |
Exosome separation based on surface charge | ||||||||
Plate gel electro- phoresis | high recovery rate, minimal damage, easy to operate | difficulty in recycling, low processing volume, lengthy duration | urine | 20 μL | 10-250 | 120 | 100 | [ |
Capillary electro- phoresis | minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | plasma | 10 μL | 100-200 | 26 | 75 | [ |
Free field electro- phoresis | high recovery rate, minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | pure exosome solution | 1 mL | 35-150 | 100 | 84.2 | [ |
Dielectrophoresis | short time consuming | low processing volume, complex operation | plasma, saliva | 200 μL | 80-200 | 20 | NA | [ |
Exosome separation based on immunoaffinity | ||||||||
Integrated lab-on- a-chip platform | high recovery rate, high specificity | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | 10 mL | 0-150 | 2000 | 90 | [ |
Wedge high mag- netic field gradi- ent mediates chip | high recovery rate, high specificity | complex operation, long time consuming, low processing volume | cell culture supernatant | 50 μL | 0-400 | 10 | NA | [ |
IMAC nanosized magnetic | high recovery rate, high specificity | low processing volume | cell culture super- natant, plasma | 1 mL | 50-500 | 5 | 90 | [ |
Supramolecular exosome array | high recovery rate, high specificity | low processing volume | saliva, urine, plasma | 10 μL | 30-140 | 40 | 71 | [ |
Table 1 Exosome isolation techniques based on microfluidics
Microfluidic technology | Advantages | Limitations | Samples | Sample volume | Isolated size/nm | Time/ min | Recovery/ % | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Exosome separation based on size | ||||||||
TFF | high throughput, con- tinuous preparation | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture super- natant, plasma | 6 mL | 0-350 | 200 | 77.80 | [ |
ExoTIC | high recovery rate, easy to operate, short time consuming | low processing volume | cell culture super- natant, urine, plasma | 10 mL | 30-100 | 125 | 90 | [ |
EXODUS | high recovery rate, easy to operate, short time consuming | low processing volume, complex equipment | cell culture super- natant, urine, tears, plasma | 10 mL | 30-200 | 10 | 100 | [ |
Electrophoresis- driven filtration | easy to operate, short time consuming | low processing volume | plasma | 1 mL | 10-400 | 30 | 65 | [ |
Nano-DLD pillar arrays | minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | urine | 10 μL | 20-110 | 50000 | NA | [ |
Viscoelastic fluid separation | high recovery | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | 1 mL | 30-500 | 50 | 86 | [ |
Inertial microflu- idics | minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | 1 mL | 0-400 | 100 | 70.60 | [ |
Acoustofluidic technology | minimal damage | complex operation | saliva | NA | 30-150 | 20 | 75 | [ |
Acoustofluidic centrifuge | high recovery rate, short time consuming | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | plasma | 80 μL | 30-150 | <1 | >80 | [ |
Coffee ring effect | minimal damage | cannot be collected | cell culture supernatant | NA | 100-200 | NA | NA | [ |
AF4 | minimal damage | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | NA | 35-150 | 50 | NA | [ |
Exosome separation based on surface charge | ||||||||
Plate gel electro- phoresis | high recovery rate, minimal damage, easy to operate | difficulty in recycling, low processing volume, lengthy duration | urine | 20 μL | 10-250 | 120 | 100 | [ |
Capillary electro- phoresis | minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | plasma | 10 μL | 100-200 | 26 | 75 | [ |
Free field electro- phoresis | high recovery rate, minimal damage | low processing volume, complex operation, lengthy duration | pure exosome solution | 1 mL | 35-150 | 100 | 84.2 | [ |
Dielectrophoresis | short time consuming | low processing volume, complex operation | plasma, saliva | 200 μL | 80-200 | 20 | NA | [ |
Exosome separation based on immunoaffinity | ||||||||
Integrated lab-on- a-chip platform | high recovery rate, high specificity | complex operation, lengthy duration | cell culture supernatant | 10 mL | 0-150 | 2000 | 90 | [ |
Wedge high mag- netic field gradi- ent mediates chip | high recovery rate, high specificity | complex operation, long time consuming, low processing volume | cell culture supernatant | 50 μL | 0-400 | 10 | NA | [ |
IMAC nanosized magnetic | high recovery rate, high specificity | low processing volume | cell culture super- natant, plasma | 1 mL | 50-500 | 5 | 90 | [ |
Supramolecular exosome array | high recovery rate, high specificity | low processing volume | saliva, urine, plasma | 10 μL | 30-140 | 40 | 71 | [ |
Microfluidics | Principles | Advantages | Limitations | Analysis objects | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Electrochemical detection | |||||
MOF-functionalized sensing | a MOF-based sensing interface for exosome capture and an enzyme- based logical gate for signal trans- duction and data processing | high selectivity | easy to be disturbed | surface marker, nucleic acid molecule | [ |
Nanopipette-assisted method | the amperometric device measures the electrochemical redox peaks generated during the release of DA from a single exosome | high sensitivity | complex operation | metabolites | [ |
Magnetic deflection detection | |||||
Magnetically driven nanomechanical sensors | magnetic fields deflect magnetic materials that bind exosomes | high sensitivity, high selectivity | complex operation | surface marker | [ |
Colorimetric detection | |||||
Colorimetric aptasensor | exosomes interact with colorimetric reagents, resulting in color changes in the solution | high sensitivity, high selectivity | easy to be disturbed | surface marker, nucleic acid mole- cule, metabolites | [ |
DNAzyme-RCA-based colorimetric and lateral flow dipstick assays | exosomes interact with colorimetric reagents, resulting in color changes in the solution | high selectivity, portable | complex operation | surface marker, nucleic acid mole- cule, metabolites | [ |
Optical detection | |||||
Exosome isolation and detection system | fluorescent probe to label exosomes | immune capture | single object | surface marker | [ |
Microfluidic surface- enhanced Raman scattering sensor | rolling circle amplification and tyramine signal amplification | high sensitivity | complex operation | nucleic acid molecule | [ |
Nanoplasmonic pillars | local surface plasmon resonance is realized by a gold nanosensor matched to the size of a single exosome | individually imaged in real time, high sensitivity | easy to be disturbed, complex operation | surface marker | [ |
Frequency-locked microtoroid optical resonators | changes in the resonant frequency of the microtoroid | high sensitivity | high requirements on samples | size, mass, polarizability | [ |
Table 2 Microfluidics for exosome analysis
Microfluidics | Principles | Advantages | Limitations | Analysis objects | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Electrochemical detection | |||||
MOF-functionalized sensing | a MOF-based sensing interface for exosome capture and an enzyme- based logical gate for signal trans- duction and data processing | high selectivity | easy to be disturbed | surface marker, nucleic acid molecule | [ |
Nanopipette-assisted method | the amperometric device measures the electrochemical redox peaks generated during the release of DA from a single exosome | high sensitivity | complex operation | metabolites | [ |
Magnetic deflection detection | |||||
Magnetically driven nanomechanical sensors | magnetic fields deflect magnetic materials that bind exosomes | high sensitivity, high selectivity | complex operation | surface marker | [ |
Colorimetric detection | |||||
Colorimetric aptasensor | exosomes interact with colorimetric reagents, resulting in color changes in the solution | high sensitivity, high selectivity | easy to be disturbed | surface marker, nucleic acid mole- cule, metabolites | [ |
DNAzyme-RCA-based colorimetric and lateral flow dipstick assays | exosomes interact with colorimetric reagents, resulting in color changes in the solution | high selectivity, portable | complex operation | surface marker, nucleic acid mole- cule, metabolites | [ |
Optical detection | |||||
Exosome isolation and detection system | fluorescent probe to label exosomes | immune capture | single object | surface marker | [ |
Microfluidic surface- enhanced Raman scattering sensor | rolling circle amplification and tyramine signal amplification | high sensitivity | complex operation | nucleic acid molecule | [ |
Nanoplasmonic pillars | local surface plasmon resonance is realized by a gold nanosensor matched to the size of a single exosome | individually imaged in real time, high sensitivity | easy to be disturbed, complex operation | surface marker | [ |
Frequency-locked microtoroid optical resonators | changes in the resonant frequency of the microtoroid | high sensitivity | high requirements on samples | size, mass, polarizability | [ |
Fig. 6 Microfluidics for exosome analysis a. schematic of the preparation of ZIF-8 modified gold electrode (ZIF-8/AuE) and the capture and analysis of exosomes[74]; b. schematic of magnetic force detection for exosomes[76]; c. schematic diagram for DNAzyme-RCA-based colorimetric and lateral flow dipstick assays for the point-of-care testing of exosomal m5C-miRNA-21[78]; d. diagram of surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy for exosome analysis[80]. DNA SAM: DNA self-assembled monolayer; AND: Logic AND gate; TSA: tyramine signal amplification; SERS: surface-enhanced Raman scatting.
Fig. 7 Disease diagnosis and clinical application of exosomes a. schematic for detection of urinary exosomal miRNA using hierarchical 3D SERS structure[87]; b. schematics of detection of PDAC exosomes using GFETs with portable electronics and real-time detection results[88]; c. iTEARS for disease detection based on a teardrop[89]. PC: prostate cancer; TCPP: tetrakis(4-carboxyphenyl)porphyrin; GPC-1: glypican-1; PDAC: pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma; GFETs: graphene field effect transistors; sEVs: small extracellular vesicles; NPO: negative-pressure-oscillation.
|
[1] | HOU Guoshan, YUAN Huiming, LIANG Zhen, ZHANG Lihua, ZHANG Yukui. Exosome separation and enrichment technologies and their applications in disease diagnosis and treatment [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(5): 434-445. |
[2] | CHEN Xiaofei, LIU Wei, ZHANG Wenjia, LI Yanpeng, WANG Zhihua, GAO Mingxia, ZHANG Xiangmin. Isolation and proteomics analysis of cerebrospinal fluid exosome subtypes [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(5): 518-528. |
[3] | WANG Haiyan, XIE Peijuan, QIAO Xiaoqiang, ZHANG Liyuan. Typical strategy and research progress of efficient isolation methods of exosomes based on affinity interaction [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(5): 413-423. |
[4] | BU Caiting, ZHU Xuedong, ZHANG Qianying, SHAO Wenya. Recent advances on the role of exosomes in neurodegenerative diseases [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(5): 487-497. |
[5] | SU Yating, QIAN Xiaohong, QIN Weijie. Research advances of liposomes and exosomes in drug delivery and biomarker screening [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(5): 472-486. |
[6] | BU Aixiang, WU Guangyao, HU Lianghai. Progress and prospect of separation and analysis of single-cell and single-particle exosomes [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(5): 399-412. |
[7] | HUANG Yuxia, WANG Haiyan, ZHANG Yihan, LIN Yifei, QIAO Xiaoqiang, HU Lianghai. Bibliometric analysis of exosomes in the biomarker research field [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(5): 498-507. |
[8] | ZHAO Yuan, LIU Xin, ZHANG Yidan, ZHANG Jian, LIU Xiang, YANG Guofeng. Tandem mass tag-based quantitative proteomics analysis of plasma and plasma exosomes in Parkinson’s disease [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2023, 41(12): 1073-1083. |
[9] | CAO Rongkai, ZHANG Min, YU Hao, QIN Jianhua. Recent advances in isolation and detection of circulating tumor cells with a microfluidic system [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2022, 40(3): 213-223. |
[10] | GUO Minkang, ZHANG Jian. Lipid metabolomic analysis in exosomes of osteonecrosis of the femoral head based on ultra performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2022, 40(2): 123-129. |
[11] | CHEN Wenwen, GAN Zhongqiao, QIN Jianhua. Microfluidic strategies for separation and analysis of circulating exosomes [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2021, 39(9): 968-980. |
[12] | WEN Hanrong, ZHU Jue, ZHANG Bo. Recent advances in microchip liquid chromatography [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2021, 39(4): 357-367. |
[13] | ZHANG Weibing, LU Rui, ZHANG Lingyi. Preparation of dual-functional composite magnetic nanomaterials modified with different metals/aptamers and their performance in exosome enrichment [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2021, 39(10): 1128-1136. |
[14] | ZHANG Hanqing, QIN Weijie, ZHANG Yangjun. Preparation of 4-mercaptophenylboronic acid functionalized two-dimensional molybdenum disulfide nanocomposite and its specific enrichment for N-glycopeptide [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2020, 38(8): 891-899. |
[15] | HUO Chunhui, LI Yinghua, QIAO Zhi, SHANG Zhi, CAO Chengxi, HONG Yang, XIAO Hua. Proteomics analysis of serum exosomes and its application in osteoporosis [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2019, 37(8): 863-871. |
Viewed | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Full text 11
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Abstract 30
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||