Chinese Journal of Chromatography ›› 2026, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (6): 615-628.DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1123.2025.06016
• Reviews • Previous Articles Next Articles
LI Shijie1,2, LI Zhen2, TANG Zixia2, LYU Mei2, WANG Litao1,2,*(
)
Received:2025-06-17
Online:2026-06-08
Published:2026-06-03
Supported by:CLC Number:
LI Shijie, LI Zhen, TANG Zixia, LYU Mei, WANG Litao. Research progress on high performance liquid chromatography stationary phases based on mixed mode[J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(6): 615-628.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX
URL: https://www.chrom-china.com/EN/10.3724/SP.J.1123.2025.06016
Fig. 2 (a) RCC3 molecular cage preparation process; (b) schematic diagrams of three different types of molecular cage stationary phases[27] TFA: trifluoroacetic acid; RT: room temperature.
| Stationary phase | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Ion-exchange interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silica-PILs | 1-(4-vinylbenzyl) -3-cyanomethyl imidazolium bromide | benzene ring | imidazole cationic substituent | polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, alkylbenzene, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
| C18/TMA | ODS, 3-glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane, TMA | ODS | quaternary ammonium group | non-polar substance, small molecule base, aromatic acid | [ |
| Sil-PBQA | amino anion exchange groups, benzene rings, and quaternary ammonium salts containing benzyl groups | benzene ring | quaternary ammonium group | nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
| Sil-VDI | VDI, thiol functionalized SiO2 | alkyl | imidazole cationic substituent | hydrophobic alkylbenzene, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and benzene derivatives, inorganic anions | [ |
| UI, PMA | alkyl, PMA | imidazole cationic substituent | EED, sulfonamide drugs, foodborne stimulants, and inorganic anions | [ | |
| Cys-silica-Cn, n=2, 8 and 18 | cysteine and vinyl functionalized SiO2, bromoethane, 1-bromooctane, and 1-bromooctadecane | alkyl | quaternary ammonium group, cysteine | 6 alkaline proteins, 5 acidic proteins | [ |
| Sil-peptoids | vinyl modified SiO2, three small peptides | hydrophobic carbon chain | -COOH, -NH2 | acidic, polar and non-polar molecules, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
Table 1 RPLC/IEC mixed-mode stationary phase information and separated substances
| Stationary phase | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Ion-exchange interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silica-PILs | 1-(4-vinylbenzyl) -3-cyanomethyl imidazolium bromide | benzene ring | imidazole cationic substituent | polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, alkylbenzene, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
| C18/TMA | ODS, 3-glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane, TMA | ODS | quaternary ammonium group | non-polar substance, small molecule base, aromatic acid | [ |
| Sil-PBQA | amino anion exchange groups, benzene rings, and quaternary ammonium salts containing benzyl groups | benzene ring | quaternary ammonium group | nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
| Sil-VDI | VDI, thiol functionalized SiO2 | alkyl | imidazole cationic substituent | hydrophobic alkylbenzene, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and benzene derivatives, inorganic anions | [ |
| UI, PMA | alkyl, PMA | imidazole cationic substituent | EED, sulfonamide drugs, foodborne stimulants, and inorganic anions | [ | |
| Cys-silica-Cn, n=2, 8 and 18 | cysteine and vinyl functionalized SiO2, bromoethane, 1-bromooctane, and 1-bromooctadecane | alkyl | quaternary ammonium group, cysteine | 6 alkaline proteins, 5 acidic proteins | [ |
| Sil-peptoids | vinyl modified SiO2, three small peptides | hydrophobic carbon chain | -COOH, -NH2 | acidic, polar and non-polar molecules, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
| Stationary phase | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Hydrophilic interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sil-AVI-ST | imidazolammonium ionic liquid, stearyl mercaptoacetate, polar ligand | alkyl | imidazole cationic substituent | sulfonamides, vitamins and nucleosides/bases, hydrophobic phthalates, bisphenols, alkylphenols and steroid hormones | [ |
| PEI/Zein@SiO2 | PEI, Zein, SiO2 | Zein | -NH2, -COOH | nucleotides, bases, antibiotics, lavonoids | [ |
| RCC3-C10@silica | RCC3 molecular cage, alkyl functional group | alkyl | -NH2, -OH | alkylbenzene, polyphenylene, phenolic, amino, sulfonamide, nucleoside, flavonoid | [ |
| RCC3-GLD@silica | epoxy propanol, RCC3-R molecular cage | hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain, benzene ring | epoxy propanol group | alkylbenzene, phenols, amines, sulfonamides, nucleosides, amino acids, sugars | [ |
| RCC3-CN@SiO2 | RCC3-R molecular cage, -CN | hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain | -CN | alkylbenzene, aromatic, phenolic, amine, sulfonamide, nucleoside, amino acid, carbohydrate | [ |
| 2D Cu-BDC/IL@silica | 2D MOFs, ILs | benzene ring | -COOH, ILs | alkaloids, sulfonamides and antibiotics | [ |
| d-MOF-919/cys@silica | MOF-919, L-Cys | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -COOH, -SH, -NH2 | PAHs, BUs, 10 carbohydrates, 8 sulfonamide drugs, 8 nucleoside/base mixtures | [ |
| d-MOF-818/PAM@silica | MOF-818, PAM | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -CONH | 9 nucleosides and bases, 8 alkaloids, 6 antibiotics, 5 alkylbenzenes | [ |
| TAPT-TP-COF@SiO2 | TAPT, TP | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -NH2, -CHO | linear alkylbenzene, phthalates, nucleosides, sulfonamides and vitamins | [ |
| PAA/COF@SiO2 | PAA, COFs | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -NH2, -CHO | aromatic ketone, alkylphenol、phthalate esters, PAHs, nucleoside compounds, alkylbenzene compounds | [ |
| COF-TpPa-1@SiO2 | Tp, Pa-1, | benzene ring | -OH | non polar alkylbenzene homologues, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, polar amines, phenols | [ |
| Sil-P-DESCDs | P-DESCDs, (3-aminopropyl)trimethoxysilane | alkyl | -COOH, -OH, -NH2 | alkylbenzene, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, sulfonamides, aromatic amines, nucleoside bases, and alkaloids | [ |
| CQDs/SiO2 | CQDs, 1,8-diaminooctane | alkyl | -COOH, -OH, -NH2 | 14 nucleosides and bases | [ |
| MON-2COOH@SiO2 | MON, -COOH, | benzene ring | -COOH | sulfonamide drugs, deoxyribonucleosides, alkaloids and endocrine disrupting chemicals | [ |
| MON-2COOH@SiO2-MER | MON, -COOH, SiO2, MER | benzene ring, alkynyl group | -COOH | hydrophobic and hydrophilic probes, sulfonamide drugs, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
| Sil-C18-IL-C4 | C18 | C18 | imidazole, ILs | nucleoside based compounds, probe molecules | [ |
| Sil-amide-C11 Sil-C12-amide | amide and hydrocarbon chain groups, 3-aminopropyl | hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain | -CONH | alkylbenzene and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons | [ |
| SiO2@COPBn-glu | COP, SiO2 | benzene ring, alkyl | -COOH | hydrophilic and hydrophobic compounds | [ |
Table 2 RPLC/HILIC mixed-mode stationary phase information and separated substances
| Stationary phase | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Hydrophilic interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sil-AVI-ST | imidazolammonium ionic liquid, stearyl mercaptoacetate, polar ligand | alkyl | imidazole cationic substituent | sulfonamides, vitamins and nucleosides/bases, hydrophobic phthalates, bisphenols, alkylphenols and steroid hormones | [ |
| PEI/Zein@SiO2 | PEI, Zein, SiO2 | Zein | -NH2, -COOH | nucleotides, bases, antibiotics, lavonoids | [ |
| RCC3-C10@silica | RCC3 molecular cage, alkyl functional group | alkyl | -NH2, -OH | alkylbenzene, polyphenylene, phenolic, amino, sulfonamide, nucleoside, flavonoid | [ |
| RCC3-GLD@silica | epoxy propanol, RCC3-R molecular cage | hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain, benzene ring | epoxy propanol group | alkylbenzene, phenols, amines, sulfonamides, nucleosides, amino acids, sugars | [ |
| RCC3-CN@SiO2 | RCC3-R molecular cage, -CN | hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain | -CN | alkylbenzene, aromatic, phenolic, amine, sulfonamide, nucleoside, amino acid, carbohydrate | [ |
| 2D Cu-BDC/IL@silica | 2D MOFs, ILs | benzene ring | -COOH, ILs | alkaloids, sulfonamides and antibiotics | [ |
| d-MOF-919/cys@silica | MOF-919, L-Cys | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -COOH, -SH, -NH2 | PAHs, BUs, 10 carbohydrates, 8 sulfonamide drugs, 8 nucleoside/base mixtures | [ |
| d-MOF-818/PAM@silica | MOF-818, PAM | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -CONH | 9 nucleosides and bases, 8 alkaloids, 6 antibiotics, 5 alkylbenzenes | [ |
| TAPT-TP-COF@SiO2 | TAPT, TP | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -NH2, -CHO | linear alkylbenzene, phthalates, nucleosides, sulfonamides and vitamins | [ |
| PAA/COF@SiO2 | PAA, COFs | hydrophobic alkyl chain | -OH, -NH2, -CHO | aromatic ketone, alkylphenol、phthalate esters, PAHs, nucleoside compounds, alkylbenzene compounds | [ |
| COF-TpPa-1@SiO2 | Tp, Pa-1, | benzene ring | -OH | non polar alkylbenzene homologues, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, polar amines, phenols | [ |
| Sil-P-DESCDs | P-DESCDs, (3-aminopropyl)trimethoxysilane | alkyl | -COOH, -OH, -NH2 | alkylbenzene, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, sulfonamides, aromatic amines, nucleoside bases, and alkaloids | [ |
| CQDs/SiO2 | CQDs, 1,8-diaminooctane | alkyl | -COOH, -OH, -NH2 | 14 nucleosides and bases | [ |
| MON-2COOH@SiO2 | MON, -COOH, | benzene ring | -COOH | sulfonamide drugs, deoxyribonucleosides, alkaloids and endocrine disrupting chemicals | [ |
| MON-2COOH@SiO2-MER | MON, -COOH, SiO2, MER | benzene ring, alkynyl group | -COOH | hydrophobic and hydrophilic probes, sulfonamide drugs, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs | [ |
| Sil-C18-IL-C4 | C18 | C18 | imidazole, ILs | nucleoside based compounds, probe molecules | [ |
| Sil-amide-C11 Sil-C12-amide | amide and hydrocarbon chain groups, 3-aminopropyl | hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain | -CONH | alkylbenzene and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons | [ |
| SiO2@COPBn-glu | COP, SiO2 | benzene ring, alkyl | -COOH | hydrophilic and hydrophobic compounds | [ |
| Stationary phase | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Ion-exchange interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sil-PolyCOOH | polyethylene maleic anhydride, SiO2-NH2 | -COOH | carboxyl ionization | nucleosides, nucleic acid bases, carbohydrate compounds, quaternary ammonium salts | [ |
| (AMPS)n-ImprSiO2 | CPTMO, V-Im, AMPS | -CONH, sulfonic acid | imidazole, sulfonic acid | sulfonamide drugs, flavonoids, various components in extracts of traditional chinese medicine ligustrum lucidum | [ |
| DCC/SiO2 | DAC, sodium chlorite,SiO2-NH2 | -COOH | -COOH | nucleosides, alkaloids and aniline compounds | [ |
| C22-A3 | long chain alkyl, polyamine groups | -NH2, -CONH | -NH2 | nucleosides, nucleotides, aromatic acid compounds, multiple organic and inorganic anions | [ |
| TPHs-SiO2 | H3L | -CONH, -NH2, -OH | -NH2 | seven nucleosides and nucleotides, five types of aniline compounds | [ |
Table 3 HILIC/IEC mixed-mode stationary phase information and separated substances
| Stationary phase | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Ion-exchange interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sil-PolyCOOH | polyethylene maleic anhydride, SiO2-NH2 | -COOH | carboxyl ionization | nucleosides, nucleic acid bases, carbohydrate compounds, quaternary ammonium salts | [ |
| (AMPS)n-ImprSiO2 | CPTMO, V-Im, AMPS | -CONH, sulfonic acid | imidazole, sulfonic acid | sulfonamide drugs, flavonoids, various components in extracts of traditional chinese medicine ligustrum lucidum | [ |
| DCC/SiO2 | DAC, sodium chlorite,SiO2-NH2 | -COOH | -COOH | nucleosides, alkaloids and aniline compounds | [ |
| C22-A3 | long chain alkyl, polyamine groups | -NH2, -CONH | -NH2 | nucleosides, nucleotides, aromatic acid compounds, multiple organic and inorganic anions | [ |
| TPHs-SiO2 | H3L | -CONH, -NH2, -OH | -NH2 | seven nucleosides and nucleotides, five types of aniline compounds | [ |
| Stationary phases | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Hydrophilic interactions | Ion-exchange interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SiO2-MPS-CQDs | CQDs, MPS, SiO2 | alkyl | -OH, -COOH | imidazole cationic substituent | alkylbenzenes, PAHs, nucleoside bases, sulfonamides, anionic compounds | [ |
| Sil-SVC, Sil-SVC-NPA | SVC, NPA | benzene ring | -COOH, -NH2 | -NH2 | hydrophobic analytes, hydrophilic nucleotides, bases and anions | [ |
| SiO2@P(St-AA) | styrene and acrylic acid as polymerization monomers, vinyltrimethoxysilane | benzene ring | -COOH | -COOH | alkylbenzene and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, nucleosides and bases, organic bases and acids | [ |
| SiO2@TpBD-(OH)2 | COPs, Tp, BD-(OH)2 | benzene ring | -COOH, -C=N- | imidazole cationic substituent | benzene homologues, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, bases, acidic organic compounds | [ |
| PIm-Br, coPIm-VBS | SiO2 polymerized imidazole ionic liquid | benzene ring, alkyl | imidazole cationic substituent | -COOH, -SO3H | nucleosides, inorganic ions and organic ions | [ |
| Sil-IM-Br, Sil-IM-SAG | IM-Br, IM-SAG, Sil-MPS | benzene ring, alkyl | -OH | imidazole cationic substituent, sulfonate group | organic chemistry, inorganic ions, vitamin | [ |
| Sil-DCH-Im2 | SiO2 polymerized imidazole ionic liquid | imidazole ring | -NH2, -CONH- | imidazole cationic substituent | hydrophilic substances, hydrophobic substances, acids and inorganic anionic substances | [ |
| Sil-PEI-APH | PEI, APH | benzene ring | -CONH, -OH | -NHR2, -N+R3 | alkylbenzenes, PAHs, nucleosides, flavonoids, aromatic amine | [ |
| Sil-G1-AS, Sil-G2-AS | BDDE, AS, ethylenediamine | octadecylamine chain | -OH, quaternary ammonium ions | quaternary ammonium ions | PAHs, alkylbenzene, nucleoside, vitamin, phenolic, aromatic amine, flavonoids compounds | [ |
| DPE-DIL, BND-DIL | DPE, BND | benzene ring | imidazole ring, -CONH, -OH | imidazole cationic substituent | nucleosides and bases, PAHs, food additives | [ |
Table 4 RPLC/HILIC/IEC mixed-mode stationary phase information and separated substances
| Stationary phases | Functional ligand | Hydrophobic interactions | Hydrophilic interactions | Ion-exchange interactions | Samples | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SiO2-MPS-CQDs | CQDs, MPS, SiO2 | alkyl | -OH, -COOH | imidazole cationic substituent | alkylbenzenes, PAHs, nucleoside bases, sulfonamides, anionic compounds | [ |
| Sil-SVC, Sil-SVC-NPA | SVC, NPA | benzene ring | -COOH, -NH2 | -NH2 | hydrophobic analytes, hydrophilic nucleotides, bases and anions | [ |
| SiO2@P(St-AA) | styrene and acrylic acid as polymerization monomers, vinyltrimethoxysilane | benzene ring | -COOH | -COOH | alkylbenzene and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, nucleosides and bases, organic bases and acids | [ |
| SiO2@TpBD-(OH)2 | COPs, Tp, BD-(OH)2 | benzene ring | -COOH, -C=N- | imidazole cationic substituent | benzene homologues, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, bases, acidic organic compounds | [ |
| PIm-Br, coPIm-VBS | SiO2 polymerized imidazole ionic liquid | benzene ring, alkyl | imidazole cationic substituent | -COOH, -SO3H | nucleosides, inorganic ions and organic ions | [ |
| Sil-IM-Br, Sil-IM-SAG | IM-Br, IM-SAG, Sil-MPS | benzene ring, alkyl | -OH | imidazole cationic substituent, sulfonate group | organic chemistry, inorganic ions, vitamin | [ |
| Sil-DCH-Im2 | SiO2 polymerized imidazole ionic liquid | imidazole ring | -NH2, -CONH- | imidazole cationic substituent | hydrophilic substances, hydrophobic substances, acids and inorganic anionic substances | [ |
| Sil-PEI-APH | PEI, APH | benzene ring | -CONH, -OH | -NHR2, -N+R3 | alkylbenzenes, PAHs, nucleosides, flavonoids, aromatic amine | [ |
| Sil-G1-AS, Sil-G2-AS | BDDE, AS, ethylenediamine | octadecylamine chain | -OH, quaternary ammonium ions | quaternary ammonium ions | PAHs, alkylbenzene, nucleoside, vitamin, phenolic, aromatic amine, flavonoids compounds | [ |
| DPE-DIL, BND-DIL | DPE, BND | benzene ring | imidazole ring, -CONH, -OH | imidazole cationic substituent | nucleosides and bases, PAHs, food additives | [ |
|
| [1] | ZHAO Xingyun, JIN Jiangyan, LIU Xiaojian, YAN Lijuan, YANG Siyu, ZHANG Zhenwei, ZHANG Liyun, WU Rongfang. Preparation of mesoporous covalent organic framework core-shell stationary phase and its application in the analysis of astragaloside Ⅳ content in Astragalus [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(6): 639-649. |
| [2] | SUN Jing, ZHANG Yu, LIU Fengmao, ZHAO Wen, JIN Yue, ZHANG Lin, XUE Xiaofeng, CHEN Rui, ZHOU Huatian. Determination of 38 antibiotic residues in honey by magnetic dispersive solid-phase extraction-liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(4): 467-478. |
| [3] | JIAO Ruiwen, ZHANG Dandan, HU Xingyuan, ZHU Wanting, LI Xiang, CAI Yidi, REN Dandan, WANG Qiukuan, WU Long, ZHOU Hui. Preparation of a novel polyhydroxy silica stationary phase and application in the separation of alginate oligosaccharides [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(4): 373-382. |
| [4] | LI Fei, JIA Baolin, HU Qiao, HE Xiwen, CHEN Langxing, ZHANG Yukui. Molecularly imprinted polymers: novel green preparation methods and cutting-edge applications review [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(2): 119-133. |
| [5] | WANG Mingwei, TIAN Tao, BAI Ligai, HAN Dandan, YAN Hongyuan. Preparation of superhydrophilic imprinted resin-graphene aerogel composite and its precise recognition of tumor biomarker in urine [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(2): 191-200. |
| [6] | ZHANG Yufan, XIA Jingwen, ZHU Jiayuan, ZENG Maosheng, BAI Jingyi, XU Qin, GAO Hang. Application of molecularly imprinted polymers-based sensors for determination of acute coronary syndrome biomarkers [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(2): 180-190. |
| [7] | QI Wanting, TONG Yukui. Design of ZIF-L-based boronate affinity molecularly imprinted material and its application in the detection of ribavirin in environmental water [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(2): 214-222. |
| [8] | CHENG Yun, LIN Yule, TIAN Miaomiao. Controlled synthesis of high-capacity bisphenol A molecularly imprinted polymer and its application to the detection of environmental water samples [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(1): 92-100. |
| [9] | YUAN Xueting, WANG Liang, CHEN Luxi, HU Lianghai. Molecular imprinting strategies and advances targeting biomembranes [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(1): 30-42. |
| [10] | WU Jiangyi, HUANG Xiaojia. Progress in electric field assisted molecular imprinting technology [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2026, 44(1): 43-52. |
| [11] | XU Gaigai, YI Yang, LIU Pingping, ZHANG Wenfen. Preparation and chromatographic performance evaluation of hydrophilic interaction chromatography stationary phase based on amino acids [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(7): 734-743. |
| [12] | ZHOU Ding, GUO Dandan, ZHU Yan. Research progress in polyamide-amine dendrimer functionalized ionic separation media [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(7): 726-733. |
| [13] | XU Qitong, YU Meng, XIE Chang, CAO Yan, MEI Surong. Recent applications of porous-material-based adsorbents for extracting pesticide residues from environmental and foodstuff samples [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(7): 713-725. |
| [14] | ZENG Lei, WEI Mengling, WEI Wei, LI Hao, SHI Bo’an, LEI Fuhou. Construction of acrylpimaric acid-bonded silica stationary phase and its application in mixed-mode chromatographic separation [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(7): 744-755. |
| [15] | LUO Yana, CHEN Jia, HU Yuyu, GAO Shijie, WANG Yanli, LIU Yanming, FENG Juanjuan, SUN Min. Research progress in material preparation and application of magnetism-enhanced in-tube solid-phase microextraction [J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2025, 43(6): 606-619. |
| Viewed | ||||||
|
Full text |
|
|||||
|
Abstract |
|
|||||